Healthy White+ vs ProtectiveClean 6100 - Which Is More Powerful

Wish I'd found this website weeks ago -- before I bought & returned several models of Sonicare toothbrushes.
I've had the Healthy White+ brush for over 3 years now & it has been the best toothbrush I've ever used - far better than an Oral-B - but I've always bought my brush heads from Costco because they are so much cheaper. However, I recently ran out of my last non-syncying brush head and put on one of the ones I bought recently from Costco -- which has the sync symbol on it -- which I didn't initially notice. It seemed a little harder to push onto the handle shaft, which is what made me notice the sync symbol, but it seemed to work OK once I got it on -- the shaft on the Healthy White+ is different than the newer sync models (6100, etc.). Because I didn't want to pay the higher cost to purchase just 2 or 3 brush heads of the old style I decided to try out the newer model while they were on sale at Bed, Bath & Beyond. After much research it looked like the ProtectiveClean 6100 was as close to the Healthy White+ as I could get in similar features - namely the 3 intensity settings. After using it for a few days I found I really didn't like the mode it chose when I put on my Premium Plaque Control head or the Diamond Clean, even when I set it to the highest intensity, so I returned it and exchanged it for the ProtectiveClean 5100 -- which I hated even more -- not only did it not have the intensity setting (which I knew in advance), but it seemed very much less powerful regardless of which setting I had it on -- so back it went. I'm now hoping my Healthy White+ will last a while longer and the Costco brush heads will not fail me -- or damage the brush handle shaft if I keep having to push the brush head down so hard.
Do you have any data that would indicate if the ProtectiveClean 6100 set on high intensity - regardless of which mode it is set on or any brush head being used -- would compare in power compared to the high intensity I use on the Clean mode of my Healthy White+? I just want to be prepared in case my Healthy White+ dies on me -- it just looks like the 6100 is going to be the closest I can get to it & I want to watch for a good sale coming up, but I also don't want a less powerful brush. Thanks.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Please answer the question so we know you're a human.